- We can begin to teach Ezra how to handle money
- Ezra doesn't fully understand that 3 pennies is not a lot of money...yet...
- We have a more hands-on tool for learning math
The most difficult behavior that Ezra struggles with (as do many 4-year olds so we're not EXTREMELY concerned) is a complaining spirit...and the opportunities for him to complain seem to have no limit -- "Time to go brush your teeth, Ezra." (complain); "Ezra your mom's here to pick you up (from the Children's Center.)" (complain); anytime we have to leave from a place he does not want to leave from...(complain); if given a new toy or a piece of candy it doesn't take him long at all to start talking about how he wants more or the next toy that will complete the "set"....it goes on and on. So, the money system works like this: If he can do the above without complaining, he gets three pennies. The big ones are the teeth brushing and the leaving of places that he wants to stay at. I actually have a bag of "rewards" in the trunk of my car to give to him if he leaves the Children's Center or the YMCA without complaining. This may seem like bribing....and maybe it is...but for now, we're cool with it. Also, keep in mind the other "rewards" he is given are usually things that he already needs. For instance, Ezra needed new underwear. Today I picked up a package of 5 pairs of Cars underwear. Guess what he got for a reward today? The package of underwear? No...1 pair of the underwear from the package...gotta make it last. And, guess what: he loved it! He's been given toothbrushes, socks, toothpaste...all the essentials you can think of. I just build it up as a reward, and he's psyched about it. I wonder if he's going to have issues when he grows up....?
Anyway...back to the money thing. It's been working out REALLY well. I can also take money away, for instance, if Ezra is wasting water when he brushes his teeth (which he LOVES to do...if he went unchecked, the water would seriously run the entire time...) He has a piggy bank on his dresser and I have a big Ziploc bag of pennies in my sock drawer.
"All right, Ezra! Time to brush your teeth and if you can do it with a good attitude, you get 3 pennies!" He is a completely different child. See, we've been trying to give him more autonomy (ie. brushing his teeth on his own (with a once-over from us after for good measure), dressing himself, putting away his toys at night and blankets in the morning, throwing his dirty clothes in the hamper, etc.) We're trying to do this without hovering over him while he's doing it. The problem with this is that he has a hard time staying on task and then, of course, forgets what he's supposed to be doing. Not only does the money help him to stay focused, but I also made a pictorial check-list of sorts for his bedroom for different tasks he does. It works REALLY well. I always tell him to check his list before he reports to me to make sure he did all the things he was supposed to do. Oddly enough, for a kid who could sit in his room ALL DAY LONG and listen to books on CD, he has a hard time focusing on what we tell him to do and following directions. So, if he reports to me and he's not done something on the checklist, he loses a penny. That's happened maybe once or twice. His ability to listen and follow directions is getting markedly better.
These little pennies here and there are like little bonuses but Ezra really brings home the bacon by doing a job. His job these days is reading. If he reads a whole book all by himself, he gets a whole dollar! If we go halfsies on the book, he gets 50 cents (which I sometimes think he likes more since I usually give him 50 pennies!) Now, keep in mind, this is not a required job. He can do it whenever and as often or as little as he wants. This has been AMAZING because while Ezra doesn't like to sit still long enough to work through a book, the incentive of the money has been too hard for him to resist! Already this week, just for reading books alone, Ezra has earned 3 dollars! That's how things really start to add up and this is where the reward really starts to get clearer. We've been doing this for about a month now and a couple weeks ago, Ezra had saved up nearly 12 dollars! Of course, we went shopping! He is really into collecting cars from the Cars movie. He had his heart set on one in particular but the store didn't have it and this is where the cool conversations about handling money happen. Of course there were many other things he was perfectly willing to buy so we picked out some options. He could pick one set of options OR wait and try to find the original car he wanted somewhere else OR continue to save the money for something bigger. It wasn't an easy decision for him and we stood in that aisle for quite some time weighing things. He finally landed on one of the options in front of him (2 new cars) and promptly began planning how he would get more money to get the other cars he wanted.
Another cool money conversation happened last week. Fridays are usually mine and Ezra's morning to do something different from the usual together. On Fridays, we will go to the library or the pool at the Y or the Science Center in downtown Louisville. I typically let Ezra make the decision but on this particular Friday, I really had already decided that we wouldn't be going to the Science Center. I have to pay $3 to park each time we go and I didn't have the cash on hand to pay it (they don't take cards) and I didn't feel like going to the bank...I also don't want to spend $12 to $15 a month on parking at the Science Center because Ezra would probably go there every Friday (we have a membership.) When I told him this news, he was downcast. I told him the situation and then I mentioned that if he really wanted to go, he had $3 in his piggy bank and he could pay to park if he wanted but that (at the time) would deplete his funds. He considered it, but then decided to go to the library instead. I LOVE that he chose to go to the library because I know that he REALLY loves to go to the Science Center. It shows that he is starting to think about what he wants to do with his funds. Really cool.
I can see this very easily leading into money for chores but don't get me wrong, though. I do believe that it's important that Ezra understands he is a part of a family and money or no money, there are things that need to be done and you just do them because you're part of this family team. But, I can really see the value in showing him that money is not only something you have to work for but something you have to learn how to manage properly. He's gonna have to do it eventually, why not try to start developing healthy habits in him at a young age...? I mean, we teach our kids how to do all the other things they will have to do as grown-ups (ie. read, wash yourself, count, prepare food, etc.), why not give them access and practical hands-on education with money? I don't know...maybe we're making a horrible mistake....
Some of you may be shaking your heads and rolling your eyes at me. I promise, Ezra is still a kid. I am not holding pennies over his head all day long and making sure he measures up. It's just become a useful tool and a preferable reward.
I apologize for the rambly way in which this has been written. I don't know how many people read this, but I sure would love to hear feedback on this whether you're a parent or not!